Saturday 28th of December 2024

Ouch ()

Many thanks to reviewer David Eastwood for his criticisms. (See Review section for the full review). My bold in the extract below shows the bits that pushed my (Lefty's) buttons particularly deftly:

...a couple of flaws in the logic I reckon: There seemed a bit of a tendency to play the man and not the ball. JWH certainly makes a convincing chief villain, but Australian politics has long been too cosy a duopoly and I'm sure it's fair to say that Labor are more than slightly complicit in trashing our democracy....

Score one for the NHJ! sceptics, at least as it applies in my chapter. It can be a battle at times for those long-frustrated types among us who have serious - and imho valid - 'ishoos' (ahem) with the PM to keep in the forefront of our mind that the man isn't actually the root of all evil in the world. And especially that, on a heartfelt matter like refugees (say), the ALP has hardly covered itself in 'bleeding heart' glory over the last few years, either. As NHJ! contributor Harry Heidelberg argues in Chapter 17 ('Ever More Democratic'), many of the democratic shortcomings identified in NHJ! will probably persist after the PM has departed.

David E's review notes on the NHJ! neo-liberal economic focus are good food for thought, too. Thanks, DE. Fire us in any thoughts his criticisms raise, all.